New Mexico Piñon Dark Piñon Single Serve Coffee Cup Allergic Reaction Lawsuit Lawyers

Coffee Pod Injury Lawsuit: What to Know If You Used New Mexico Piñon Coffee Dark Piñon Single Serve Cups

Coffee pods are a staple in homes and offices across New York. Their convenience, affordability, and wide availability have made them popular with consumers of all ages. But when a trusted brand like New Mexico Piñon Coffee issues a national recall for a product that could pose contamination risks, it raises serious legal and public health concerns. Consumers who may have unknowingly used these potentially compromised pods deserve clarity on what happened, what the risks are, and whether they have a right to compensation.

On July 18, 2025, New Mexico Piñon Coffee announced a recall of its Dark Piñon Single Serve Cups (lot code 251749), citing possible food coloring contamination that could be introduced into the cup during brewing. Although no injuries have been reported and the FDA categorized this as a Class III recall (meaning adverse health consequences are unlikely), the situation still creates a risk profile that may warrant legal attention for some consumers. Understanding how recalls are handled and what your rights are is crucial for protecting yourself and your family.

What the Recall Involves and Why It Matters

The product in question is the New Mexico Piñon Coffee Dark Piñon Single Serve Cups, 10-count box, lot code 251749. The potential issue involves a defect during the manufacturing process that allows food coloring to be introduced into the brewed cup of coffee. While this may sound minor at first glance, contamination from unintended substances during consumption raises safety concerns.

Even if the FDA currently considers this a Class III recall, such classification does not guarantee zero risk. A Class III recall simply means that the likelihood of harm is low. However, each person may react differently to additives or contaminants, and some may have allergic or other adverse reactions not anticipated by regulatory agencies.

Products were distributed across the United States and sold at various retailers, both in-store and online. The company has asked consumers to either throw away the affected product or return it to the point of purchase for a refund.

How Contamination Can Affect Consumers

Ingestion of unintended substances, even food coloring, can pose health concerns, especially for individuals with allergies, compromised immune systems, or preexisting health conditions. While food-grade dyes are generally considered safe in regulated quantities, the issue becomes serious when the process allows an unknown or unmeasured amount of a substance to enter the product. That lack of control over dosage and chemical exposure could place certain individuals at greater risk than others.

For example, individuals with sensitivities to artificial dyes might experience headaches, gastrointestinal upset, or skin reactions. If the coloring agent is not approved for food use or was introduced by way of an unintended chemical interaction, there could be toxicological implications depending on the nature of the compound.

Legal Liability: What Consumers Should Know

Even when a recall is voluntary, manufacturers are still legally responsible for ensuring their products are safe. Under product liability laws, companies that sell defective or contaminated products can be held accountable for any resulting harm. The three primary legal theories of liability include:

• Manufacturing Defect – If the contamination occurred due to a flaw in the production line, affected consumers may have grounds for legal action.
• Failure to Warn – If the manufacturer failed to adequately inform the public or delayed the recall notification, that could form the basis for liability.
• Breach of Warranty – Consumers are entitled to expect that a product will work as intended and be safe for consumption. If the product fails to meet those expectations, a breach may be claimed.

Anyone who experienced symptoms, had to seek medical attention, or incurred expenses due to this issue may have a right to compensation.

What You Can Do if You Used This Product

If you purchased the New Mexico Piñon Coffee Dark Piñon Single Serve Cups and have experienced any adverse effects or are concerned about your exposure, it is important to:

1. Preserve the Evidence: If you still have the box or remaining pods, keep them as they may be needed for testing.
2. Document Your Experience: Write down when and where you purchased the product, how many times you used it, and any symptoms or issues experienced.
3. Seek Medical Evaluation: If you are unsure whether your symptoms are related to the product, get checked by a physician.
4. Report to Authorities: File a complaint with the FDA via their MedWatch reporting system.

Most importantly, consider speaking to a product liability attorney to determine whether your case meets the legal standards for compensation.

Why Legal Help Matters in Recalls Like These

Manufacturers and large food distributors often have teams of lawyers ready to protect their interests. Consumers, on the other hand, may feel powerless or unsure if their complaints matter. But laws exist specifically to protect consumers when defective or dangerous products make it to the market.

While no injuries have yet been officially documented, the purpose of consumer protection law is not only to address harm after it happens, but to deter negligent manufacturing practices and hold companies accountable for selling unsafe products. If this recall grows or if people begin reporting adverse reactions, lawsuits may be necessary to ensure justice and encourage greater safety oversight.

Parker Waichman LLP has a national reputation for helping victims of recalled products. Our attorneys understand how to gather evidence, work with medical experts, and go up against corporate legal teams to ensure your voice is heard.

Contact Parker Waichman LLP For a Free Case Review

If you or someone you know used the recalled New Mexico Piñon Coffee pods and experienced adverse symptoms, protect your rights. You may be entitled to financial compensation for medical bills, lost income, or other damages. Parker Waichman LLP is currently investigating cases related to this recall and is offering a free consultation to help you determine the strength of your case.

Call 1-800-YOUR-LAWYER (1-800-968-7529) now to speak with an attorney. Don’t wait to take action if your health has been put at risk by a defective consumer product. Regardless of your location or where your injury occurred, our nationwide product injury law firm is ready to assist you.